Immigration and Identity

Atul Bhattarai
February 18, 2016

Arts Policy Nexus

(To read other articles in our Arts-Policy Nexus series click here.)

APN 96 immigration identity

Immigrants of any kind often face a personal dilemma: Who are they in a new, foreign space? A group of four immigrant and foreign-born artists were confronted with that question in the course of volunteering with elderly immigrants—through “multilingual art-making projects, recreation activities, and conversations”—as part of an Engaging Artists residency at MoreArt, an organization that connects professional artists with communities. In a roundtable at the Queens Museum on Feb. 7, the artists spoke about how their identities, as immigrants and artists, were challenged by the experience.

The artists-in-residence, accompanied by two other panelists, ranged widely in nationality (as well as artistic discipline): Aurélien Grèzes, from France; Guido Garaycochea, from Peru; Hidemi Takagi, from Japan; Andrew Nemr, from Canada and Lebanon; Raúl Ayala, from Ecuador; and Silvia Ortiz, the panel’s moderator, from Colombia. Having entered the residency as artists, many were taken aback when they found the seniors they worked with resistant to being included in their art. Grèzes, a video artist, felt as if he had come to “face a wall.” Garaycochea, whose form extends across several media, said that he tried to acquaint the seniors with his work, to little avail: “They said, what do you want from us? Why are you just showing up and asking for material? They said … [the art] would be for my convenience and not theirs.”

When several of the artists did break through to the seniors, it was not by clinging to a sense of purpose about their work, but by suspending their agenda. Some chose to think of the residency as an exchange. (Nemr, who is a tap dancer, found the idea of a transaction between generations, the idea of demanding reciprocity after developing trust, foreign. Tap dancing, he said, is a form with a strong oral tradition, “based on the older generation entrusting something to you: ‘This is for you, you decide who to give it to.’ And so there’s a lot of paranoia … if somebody strange comes into that context and says, I want what you have.”) But swallowing the idea of a residency-as-exchange required a review of priorities. “I didn’t think it was moral for me to go to a place and give with the intention of producing a piece of art. That was a rule for me,” Garaycochea said of his past volunteer work. “During this residency, I questioned that rule.” Ortiz reframed the issue: “As volunteers you are not freely giving. There are other kinds of exchanges that are happening. You’re getting something emotional, or you’re getting knowledge.” For their part, the artists offered empathy and a willingness to listen; engaging the seniors meant drawing trust and finding common ground. “They need to know you are not just taking advantage of them,” Garaycochea said.

For Garaycochea, the seniors’ suspicions reflect the isolating reality of the immigrant experience—the relative, if implicit, constraints on community that exist in a place like New York. In Latin America, he said, cities are planned around plazas—spaces that encourage strangers to talk and interact without an agenda, allowing a sense of community to flourish. When he asked Americans where they met people, the answer they gave, he said, was “the mall.” And prejudice only deepens that isolation. “In America, if you have an accent, you need to prove that you can think, that you are capable … that you are human.”

At the same time, in a foreign place, immigrants cluster and cohabit, and strong bonds form between people who share what Garaycochea called the “trauma of displacement.” An immigrant’s identity, hemmed in on some fronts, is enriched and expanded on others. For example, Ortiz, who was born in Colombia, grew up in Queens, and traveled little in her formative years, has a “deep love” for Dominican Spanish. And when she recently visited Ecuador, she found herself strongly attached to the country and its people. “When I was in Colombia I didn’t know anyone who wasn’t Colombian,” she said. “We think about South America as one … but for most of the people there are few times when we connect with each other.” Living in Queens, with its richly diverse population—nearly half foreign-born—extended her solidarity to a wider swath of the Latin American community. “It’s about the relationships I built when I was here.”

On the other hand, Nemr said that constantly being on the road has caused him to be wary of stretching his identity to its extremes. “The only way I can keep my sanity is by not having a national identity,” he said. “I think it’s most important to be able to honor other people’s identities and views than to say ‘I accept everything.’ Otherwise our own identities are lapsed.” For most immigrants, retaining identity, in its many facets, is a worthy challenge, as the panelists found. For many, “the giving of stories is the same thing as the giving of wisdom,” Nemr said. Ortiz reasoned that the seniors’ resistance to the artists might have come from their desire to assert agency and independence—to be able to choose whether and with whom to impart their experience and stories in a country where immigrants assimilate and identities inevitably blur and converge. For a long time, she said, “teachers told mothers who spoke Spanish at home that they were bad mothers.” Nemr, who was raised in Canada, volunteered that his parents had been under similar pressure: “They made a very specific choice to teach me English first so that I wouldn’t have an accent as I was growing up.”

Immigrants, Nemr said, harbor a “dissonance between their identity and the mainstream identity”; it’s a question of how the two are reconciled. In trying to find balance, one’s identity asserts itself, especially if it is cast into the margins. “My partner’s grandmother migrated from Germany right before the Second World War,” Ortiz said. “At the time, there was so much shame and stigma around being German. Nobody spoke German. But he distinctly remembers that when nobody else was in the room, when he was on her lap, she would sing German songs to him. The minute somebody entered the room, the singing would stop.”

A second generation Colombian in the audience said that she was brought up not to think about her heritage. “We’re not taught here as kids to worry about the world, because we’re taught that New York is the world, and we are the capital.” The process of reconciling her dual identity began only when she was sent to Colombia for the first time as a teenager; and it was prefaced by a discovery of what it meant to be Colombian in the first place. Encountering a new identity was traumatic. “I questioned my values, I thought everything I learned growing up here just meant nothing,” she told the artists. “It’s been a challenge trying to find that balance between being American and being Colombian as well. I’m always trying to connect with my roots.”


Atul Bhattarai is an editorial assistant at World Policy Journal.
Nicole Bennett contributed to the reporting of this article.

[Photo courtesy of MoreArt]

Atul Bhattarai

Atul Bhattarai is an editorial assistant at World Policy Journal.

One thought on “Immigration and Identity

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.