Pedagogy, Otherwise

Introduction by Alessandra Pomarico, series editor

There is general consensus and a vast body of literature arguing that the education system is failing us. In the age of a global knowledge economy, the production of knowledge is becoming a financial enterprise and the logic of the market regulates every aspect of society, including how education is organized; we need to analyze the crisis of education in relation to the larger, self-reproducing, socio-economic and political crisis, which is also a crisis of the imagination. Neoliberal forces with their exploitative relationship to the world are putting our communities at risk by altering the emergent, relational, and co-dependent character of the natural and cultural ecologies within which we live. They are destroying the commons, including the diversity of the cultural ones. The primary focus of a new pedagogy, or a pedagogy otherwise, should be the promotion of a different learning that prepares us for an ecologically sustainable and socially just future.

Education is part of the apparatus designed to maintain the status quo (one of the institutionnes totales for Foucault); schools and universities can be the very place where the “mono culture of the mind” is forged, and cultural trauma and segregation is perpetuated while knowledge becomes yet another commodity. We mostly refer to education using the dominant discourses of the colonial, modernist Eurocentric and westernized imaginary, which excludes or attempts to assimilate other systems of knowledge, other cosmogonies and economies. What we need to learn today is how we can avoid reproducing such asymmetrical, exploitative dynamics towards other beings, and how we can sustain pedagogies that are not based on oppressive, patriarchal, and extractive patterns.

Read More
Can we imagine a non-hegemonic, post-Capitalistic framework for learning? Some argue that we need to unlearn before we can learn what we don’t know.

If the education system can be the instrument of oppression and subjugation, aggravating polarization ,and causing psychological and cultural traumas, the process of learning constitutes on the other hand a step toward emancipation, self-development and collective transformation. Many radical thinkers in the course of history have attributed to pedagogy a seminal role in the struggle for human rights and in the liberation movements.

We believe that to critically reflect on, and re-imagine the pedagogical process, supporting the formation of autonomous zones of learning, is fundamental to any attempt to produce a paradigmatic shift, necessary in a moment of social and environmental catastrophe. We also consider that collective learning, and learning about collectivity, are particularly urgent while we witness the privatization and segmentation of every sphere of life, an individualistic atomization of the human being, and the transformation of community spaces and times, into virtual, so called “social” media. At costs still hard to evaluate, both in terms of anthropological behavioral changes and of voluntary concessions to a more and more invasive system of techno- surveillance.

This space dedicated to pedagogy — in the larger context of conversations that ArtsEverywhere is providing — will constitute an additional platform for an organic, interdisciplinary, and intersectional reflection, a framework for an open yet situated discussion around what it takes today to “unfold learning societies”[1] and to co-create “really useful knowledge.”[2]

Through a series of essays published once a month, we will deepen the dialogue around “pedagogy, otherwise” from a radical perspective, one that wishes to be informed not only by critical thinking (as criticism is today easily reabsorbed by the hegemonic discourse, following Rancière) but also by the existing alternative practices, those experiments thriving to reclaim the right to self-organize the learnings (as well as other fundamental areas of life) assuming the responsibility to self-regenerate communities, focusing on pedagogy as politics.

We hope to provide a space to “learn how to learn” from a polyphony of positions, practices, and experiences. We will invite heterogeneous — at times even discordant — voices, proposing a variety of approaches and media. We will explore unorthodox methodologies, ideas, and technologies emerging from grassroots, queer, informal, non-vertical, non-academic, community-based, and context-oriented processes; we will consider activist- and artist-led procedures for sharing and developing critical learning tools; protocols of convivial and militant researches; insurgent knowledge from communities in struggle; and investigate the ecology of knowledge in an attempt to decolonize learning structures (and superstructures) through a wider epistemological diversity.

We will discover how some convergent spaces and temporary zones of autonomous learning have been created both in the global North and the global South. We will investigate how different pedagogical relationships can stem from an artistic perspective, and how artists articulate the relational pedagogical tension through their works and processes. Whether contemporary artists are organizing independently their own schools or pedagogical initiatives, or they are activating the space of the exhibition as a didactical opportunity, expanding the role of the museum and engaging a deep dialogue with the audience, we are witnessing the transformative potential of art, the generative effect of collective learning, as art-led researches processes are developing both practice-led theory and theory-active practice, impacting the social sphere and the life of communities, far beyond the art world.

During the spring and summer, we will let our readership take a voyage into these differently oriented contributions around pedagogy, that will conclude with a annotated bibliography of selected influential critical pedagogues, theoreticians, and thinkers that have significantly contributed to the topic. In the fall we will invite respondents to discuss the ideas and themes that emerged, in the form of a round table, with shorter essays furthering our conversation.

Also, chronicles from our practices at Free Home University will implement the focus on alternative and radical pedagogies directly from the field. We will report from other artistic, indigenous, activist initiatives, real life platforms and conferences, self-organized networks, non-governmental cultural infrastructures and extra-state agencies, and from all those “brave spaces” where sharing knowledge differently is a way to create a different world.

[1] “Unfolding Learning Societies: Experiencing the Possibilities.” Vimukt Shiksha: A Bulletin of Shikshantar, June 2002. Accessed May 15, 2016. http://www.swaraj.org/shikshantar/ls3_intro.htm.
[2] “Really useful knowledge” is a notion that the curatorial collective WHW explores through the group exhibition with international artists at Museo National Centro de Arte Reina Sophia, and a connected publication.

Performing the Struggle: Chapter Three
Scars, Giant Face, Ferocious Breakdance, and Other Learning Props to Perform the Struggle: A Play as Remembered by a Participant

N.O. aka Aliosha Pantalone, St. Petersburg 

This is chapter three of three. For the first chapter in the series, please click here. For the second chapter in the series, please click here. Cast: Abimbola (Abimbola Odugbesan) Nigerian freedom fighter, dedicates most of his time to self-organized refugee groups like Lampedusa in Hamburg, Here to Participate (program...

Performing the Struggle: Chapter Two
Away from Home in Lecce

Christina Thomopoulos, Athens 

This is chapter two of three. For the first chapter in the series, please click here. For the third chapter in the series, please click here. Foreign Postcards: A Series of Rituals around Language, Memory, and Music When was the first time you remember hearing the word “foreigner”? What happened? From whom...

Performing the Struggle: Chapter One

Alessandra Pomarico, New York City & Lecce, Italy 

Just as the way we perform changes, so should our sense of “voice.” In our everyday lives we speak differently to diverse audiences. We communicate best by choosing that way of speaking that is informed by the particularity and uniqueness of whom we are speaking to and with. […] The...

Radical Pedagogy is NOT

Alessandra Pomarico, New York City & Lecce, Italy 
N.O. aka Aliosha Pantalone, St. Petersburg 

Part one: To no list Foreword by Alessandra Pomarico (inspired by many). It was a real struggle to define, in a 10 minute text, “the partisan No” that originates and informs the experience of Free Home University—an ongoing, experimental, open-ended pedagogical process—while being immersed in one of our sessions: 25...

Learning to learn in a context of war

Edgardo García, Oaxaca 

Ecoversities Gathering of Kindred Folk Re-imagining Higher Education Introduction by Kelly Tamey and Udi Mandel, co-hosts of the unconference with Manish Jain There is a knowledge movement slowly building all over the world, often under the radar of the media (mainstream and otherwise). This knowledge movement is an emerging network...

Really Useful Knowledge

What, How & for Whom, Zagreb 

The following text originally appeared in the catalogue published on the occasion of the exhibition Really Useful Knowledge, curated by What, How & for Whom/WHW and organized and produced by the Museo Nacional Centro De Arte Contemporanea Reina Sofía. The catalogue offers a further occasion to the contributing artists to...

Insurgent Learning and Convivial Research: Universidad de la Tierra, Califas

Manuel Callahan, San Jose 

Insurgent Learning and Convivial Research: Universidad de la Tierra, Califas[1] Knowledge production has increasingly become central to emancipatory projects. More and more people in struggle recognize the importance of learning and research as an essential part of movement and also an essential part of those moments of the future in...

In The Cracks of Learning (Situating Us)

Alessandra Pomarico, New York City & Lecce, Italy 

As a preamble, I’d like to clarify that every­thing I attempt to contribute in the following text on the subject of pedagogy is a recollection of ideas that have been collectively produced and experienced through convivial gatherings, dialogues, inquiries, critical reflec­tions, readings, and actions with many friends with whom I experimented...

Multi-layered Selves: Colonialism, Decolonization and Counter-Intuitive Learning Spaces

Vanessa de Oliveira Andreotti, Vancouver 

As I wondered about the best way to write this text, two related events caught my attention. First, I received a call for publications with the title “After De-colonizing…What?” issued after an extremely productive (albeit difficult) 2015 gathering in Portugal on the theme of ‘Eco-versities’. In the same week, in...

Torpor and Awakening

Vanessa de Oliveira Andreotti, Vancouver 

This text is an adapted transcript of a keynote presented at the Indigenous Scholars Conference: Indigenous Epistemologies: Re-Visioning Reconciliation on 26 March 2015, at the University of Alberta. It has been accepted for publication in the Canadian Journal of Native Studies. I am from a family with Indigenous Latin American...

Alternative Institutions and Intimate Counter-Publics: Chto Delat’s School for Engaged Art and Rosa’s House of Culture

Jonathan Brooks Platt, Pittsburgh 

The following essay is the first in a monthly series on pedagogy, edited by Alessandra Pomarico, co-curator of the Free Home University in Lecce, Italy. Alessandra introduces the series here. In the context of contemporary Russian artistic and intellectual life, the significance of the Chto Delat School for Engaged Art...